In Chapter 3, Pip wakes up early in the morning collects the food and the file and the whittles and heads off towards the marshes and the battery. He encounters a man who is another convict and not the same one who forced him to collect these items. He then finds the man and gives him all of the items and the man eats the food. Pip then returns home where he meets Joe and goes to church with him. In Chapter 4, they return to the house to have the traditional Christmas dinner with Mr. Pumblechook, Mr. Wopsle and Mrs. Hubble where they have a go at Pip knowing he cannot respond. Mrs. Gargery asks Mr. Pumblechook to have a bit of brandy and Pip is worried as he filled it with some water.